Skip to content

Variable Compensation

Results-Based Bonus in Companies: How It Works and How to Calculate It

Results-based bonus in companies: how it works, when it becomes salary, how to calculate it with goals and KPIs, and how it differs from PLR.

Raquel Marinho11 min read

Results-Based Bonus in Companies: How It Works and How to Calculate It

A results-based bonus is the amount a company pays an employee, a team or an area when the goals agreed before the period are met. It is one of the forms of variable compensationopens in a new tab and is paid only when a given result is achieved.

People who receive the bonus often ask whether the amount will become salary and how to know the math is right. People who run the program and do not yet master the calculation and the variations of the process ask the same questions. The answers depend on the legal design of the program, on clear goals, on a calculation rule written before the cycle and on reliable data at payout.

National Variable Compensation Overview

Download the full research, with data and analysis from compensation experts (in Portuguese).

What is a results-based bonus in companies?

A results-based bonus is the additional payment a company makes when previously defined goals are met. The amount varies with measured performance and is added to salary, without replacing it.

In private companies governed by the CLT (Brazil’s Consolidated Labor Laws), this payment can take different forms. It can be a cash amount, a percentage of salary, a sum tied to the score on an indicator dashboard or a reward such as a trip or a gift card. What identifies a results-based bonus is the link to a result agreed before the period.

The results-based bonus is also used in public companies and mixed-capital companies. Those that carry out economic activity follow the legal regime of private companies, labor law included (Constitution, art. 173, §1, II), and PLR in federal state-owned companies follows specific guidelines set by the Executive Branch, under art. 5 of Law 10.101/2000.

Public servants’ pay can only be set or changed by specific law (Constitution, art. 37, X), so servant bonuses are outside the scope of this article.

In the National Variable Compensation Overview, a Siteware survey, 44.6% of respondents use PLR or PPR as their main variable compensation model.

The bonus is the main model for 22.8%, commission for 20.7% and other models for 11.9%. Names change from one company to another, which is why the difference between each model matters for the legal and tax treatment of the payment.

What is the difference between results-based bonus, PLR, PPR, bonus and commission?

The difference lies in how the payment is negotiated, in the calculation base and in the treatment the law gives each model.

PLR (profit or results sharing) is regulated by Law 10.101/2000 and requires negotiation between the company and its employees, through a joint committee with a union representative or through a collective agreement.

The program is usually called PPRopens in a new tab when participation is measured by goals, results and deadlines agreed in advance.

Results-based bonus is the most common everyday name for payment tied to goals. When it comes from an internal policy, without the negotiation that Law 10.101 provides for, the payment is not treated as PLR and its classification falls under the CLT rules, the subject of the next section.

A bonus is an additional amount, usually tied to the performance of a person or team in a period, defined by the company itself. Commission is a percentage on sales or commercial results.

A gratification is an additional payment granted by the company and can become part of salary when it becomes habitual.

Is a results-based bonus considered salary?

It depends on how the program was designed and documented. The law treats PLR, awards and commission differently, and a wrong classification can generate charges and labor liabilities.

For PLR, art. 3 of Law 10.101/2000 establishes that the payment does not replace or complement pay, is not a basis for labor charges and is not subject to the principle of habituality. These protections apply when PLR follows the procedure set by law, with a negotiated instrument and clear, objective rules.

Art. 457 of the CLT covers the remaining cases. Paragraph 1 includes in salary the fixed amount agreed, legal gratifications and commissions. Paragraph 2 says that awards, even if habitual, are not part of pay and are not a basis for labor and social security charges.

Paragraph 4 defines awards as liberalities granted in goods, services or money, to an employee or a group, for performance above what is ordinarily expected.

In practice, the policy must make clear whether the payment is an award for performance above expectations or a predictable part of the pay package. When the goal is routine and the payment happens every month without a written criterion, its classification as an award can be challenged. The company’s legal team should validate the design before the first payment.

What is the tax treatment of a results-based bonus?

Taxation depends on how the payment is classified. Each model follows different rules, and the company’s accounting team confirms the treatment before the first payment.

For PLR, Law 10.101/2000 determines that income tax applies exclusively at source, separately from other income, based on its own annual table, and that the amount is not part of the annual tax return base.

PLR paid under the specific law is also outside the INSS contribution salary (Law 8.212/1991, art. 28, §9) and FGTS (Law 8.036/1990, art. 15, §6).

Awards are also outside the contribution salary and FGTS, and art. 457, §2, of the CLT rules out labor and social security charges on them.

Income tax, however, applies to awards, because Decree 9.580/2018 (art. 36, IV) includes gratifications, participations, percentages and awards among taxable income from employment. The part that is part of salary, such as commission, enters the INSS and FGTS bases.

Because the classification changes the cost of the program, it must be defined in the policy design, before the first cycle.

How does a results-based bonus program work in practice?

A results-based bonus program works in cycles. The company defines who participates, which goals count and how the amount is calculated, tracks the result during the period and pays after the calculation.

The most common steps to set up the program are:

  1. form a committee responsible for the program;
  2. define the program’s objectives;
  3. establish eligibility and calculation criteria;
  4. choose the goals and performance indicators;
  5. write the rulebook and share it with all participants;
  6. build the communication plan;
  7. track the result during the cycle, calculate and pay;
  8. evaluate the program and adjust it for the next cycle.

The rulebook and goals must be announced before the calculation period starts, as in any variable compensation program. For PLR, the law considers rules signed at least 90 days before the single or final installment as previously established.

How to calculate a results-based bonus?

The calculation of variable compensation combines the bonus target amount, the achievement of each goal and the weight of each indicator. The basic formula multiplies the target amount by the sum of each indicator’s weight times the achievement of the corresponding goal.

An illustrative example, in a manufacturing company. A production employee has a target amount of R$ 3,000 per semester and three indicators:

  • industrial productivity, with a weight of 50% and achievement of 100%;
  • maintenance cost per unit, with a weight of 30% and achievement of 90%;
  • safety index, with a weight of 20% and achievement of 80%.

The weighted sum is 0.5 × 1.00 + 0.3 × 0.90 + 0.2 × 0.80, equal to 0.93. The amount to pay is R$ 3,000 × 0.93, that is, R$ 2,790.

The company can also define a trigger, a minimum condition for the program to pay. If the financial result stays below 80% of the goal, for example, the amount to pay is zero, whatever the achievement of the other indicators. The floor and the cap on achievement limit the minimum and maximum payment.

How to define goals and indicators for a results-based bonus?

Bonus goals must be specific, measurable, attainable, relevant and time-bound, and each one needs an owner and an indicator that measures the result. These are the criteria of SMART goalsopens in a new tab.

In the Overview, 40.6% of respondents point to poorly defined goals as the main pain of the variable compensation program. That is why defining goals is the stage that deserves the most time in the program design.

Many companies combine goals at different levels. Among the Overview respondents, 61% use individual goals, 60% use corporate or strategic goals and 54% use team goals, and each respondent could choose more than one option.

What mistakes undermine a results-based bonus in companies?

The most common mistakes in variable compensation involve goals, rules, data and communication with the employee. The main ones are:

  • unattainable goals, which demotivate the team and make the program lose credibility, and goals that are too easy, which pay without generating results;
  • rewards without context, unrelated to the development plan and to each employee’s responsibilities, which reduces the meaning of recognition;
  • bonuses that are too frequent, which create the expectation of fixed pay and increase the risk of the amount being treated as part of salary;
  • rules changed in the middle of the cycle, which cause disputes;
  • outdated spreadsheets and data without a traceable source.

The Overview shows the size of the operational challenge. 61.3% of respondents still use spreadsheets in some stage of variable compensationopens in a new tab and 83.5% report medium or high effort to close the cycle.

How to manage a results-based bonus with technology?

Stratws, the AI platform for strategic and performance management created by Siteware, connects company goals to each employee’s dashboard and calculates the bonus by the rule defined in the program.

On the platform, the company creates results programs, such as a sales commission program, another for general performance evaluation and a third for PLR. The main features are:

  • a dashboard per employee, with an automatically calculated score and a traffic light showing whether the result is below or within what is expected;
  • custom formulas and triggers tied to the indicators, which protect the company from paying when the result is below expectations;
  • corporate indicators, such as net profit and revenue, and area or role indicators on the same dashboard;
  • a calculation report that records the moment of the calculation, like a frozen dashboard, and preserves the integrity of the information.

Rule-based calculation affects closing time. Grupo Fácilopens in a new tab recorded an 80% reduction in PLR closing time with Stratws. The gain comes from a consistent, traceable calculation, and each company starts from a different situation.

A results-based bonus in companies works when goals are clear, the rule is written before the cycle and the calculation is reliable. Legal classification and taxation are part of the program design from the start.

If you want to know how to calculate the amount due by the program’s rule and keep the history of each closing, visit our site and learn about the PLR and variable compensation management of Stratwsopens in a new tab.

Frequently asked questions

Is a results-based bonus the same as PLR?

Not necessarily. PLR is regulated by Law 10.101/2000 and requires negotiation with employees, through a joint committee or a collective agreement, plus clear and objective rules. A results-based bonus can be created by internal policy, and the classification of the payment, as an award or another type, defines the charges.

How to record a results-based bonus?

Recording the bonus in payroll follows the nature of the payment defined in the policy. PLR paid under the specific law and awards are outside the contribution salary and FGTS, and the part that is part of salary carries payroll charges. Accounting confirms the classification before the first payment.

Who can receive a results-based bonus?

The employees defined as eligible in the program rulebook. In the Overview, 46% of companies include all employees in variable compensation, and many of the others direct the program to managers, tactical teams or senior leadership. In PLR, the law requires the negotiation instrument to bring clear and objective rules on participation.

What is the ideal frequency for paying a results-based bonus?

The frequency follows the goal cycle and can be quarterly, semiannual or annual. In PLR, Law 10.101/2000 forbids payment more than twice in the same calendar year and at intervals shorter than a calendar quarter.

Raquel Marinho

About the author

Raquel Marinho

LinkedInopens in a new tab

Raquel is a Journalist and works as a Marketing Analyst at Siteware, where she writes about management, performance and people. With more than 5 years producing content on these topics, her work is translating complex strategic management subjects into clear, useful content for those who lead teams and results day to day.

How many decisions from your last meeting left with an owner and a deadline?

Talk to a Siteware expert about your management scenario.

Schedule a demo

Your privacy options

Necessary cookies are always on to ensure that all of the website's features work properly. The others are only stored if you allow them here, and you can change your mind at any time.

Cookie Policy